Common Sense Investing: The Triumph of Indexing

John C. Bogle’s “The Little Book of Common Sense Investing” champions an idea that has become more relevant than ever: simplicity and low-cost index funds are the key to long-term investment success. This briefing draws on Bogle’s wisdom and some common misconceptions about investment probabilities, offering a clear roadmap for anyone looking to avoid the typical pitfalls of speculative investing.

Listen to conversational overview:

The Illusion of Outperformance

In the short term, the stock market is a cacophony of distractions, driven more by speculative returns than actual business growth. Price-to-earnings ratios fluctuate wildly, while the true growth of companies – earnings and dividends – remains a steadier metric. Benjamin Graham, a revered figure in the investment world, summed it up well: “In the short run, the stock market is a voting machine . . . but in the long run, it is a weighing machine.” Yet investors often fall into the trap of believing they can outsmart the market, despite being a part of it.

It’s a fundamental truth: as a group, investors cannot consistently outperform the market. Why? Because they *are* the market. Any attempt to “beat” it comes with a hefty price – costs, fees, and taxes that erode returns. In trying to outguess the market, what was once a winner’s game (owning businesses) becomes a loser’s game (trying to outmanoeuvre the collective wisdom of all investors).

The Power of Indexing

This is where index funds come into their own. Instead of chasing the next hot stock or fund manager, index funds simply hold all the stocks in a given market, capturing the full return of that market over time. Burton Malkiel, another well-known voice in finance, describes their appeal: “Index funds are . . . tax friendly, allowing investors to defer the realisation of capital gains or avoid them completely if the shares are later bequeathed.”

The data is unequivocal. Over decades, index funds consistently outperform the majority of actively managed funds, particularly after accounting for costs and taxes. This pattern holds true across various asset classes – stocks, bonds, and even money market funds.



The Pitfalls of Active Management

Yet many investors fall prey to the seductive appeal of active management, lured by the prospect of outperformance. Selecting funds based on past performance – a behaviour known as performance chasing – is, quite simply, a terrible strategy. Jason Zweig pulls no punches: “Buying funds based purely on their past performance is one of the stupidest things an investor can do.”

Even financial advisers, while offering potentially useful guidance on other aspects of personal finance, cannot reliably choose funds that will outperform the market. High fees and costs tied to active management are a persistent drag on returns, creating a steep hill for managers to climb before they can even think about delivering above-market results.

The Wisdom of Simplicity and Discipline

Simplicity, low cost, and discipline are the cornerstones of investment success. For nearly two decades, John Bogle has championed the benefits of index funds. “Low annual expenses and minimal transaction costs” should be at the heart of any investment strategy, as Bogle frequently argued.

Broad diversification across the entire market, combined with regular rebalancing and the discipline to stay the course through market ups and downs, is the surest way to achieve financial goals. Resisting the urge to pursue complex strategies or “beat the market” will serve investors far better in the long run. As Jim Wiandt puts it: “Don’t believe the hype. Try to beat the market – in any manner – and you’re likely to get beat.”

It’s not just index fund advocates like Bogle who believe in this approach. Warren Buffett, perhaps the most famous investor of all time, is a staunch supporter of indexing, especially for the average investor. Even Benjamin Graham, who made his name as a value investor, highlighted the importance of long-term ownership and broad diversification, stating: “The real money in investment will be made not out of buying and selling but of owning and holding securities.”

ETFs: The Dark Side of Indexing

While Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) share many of the same advantages as index funds, such as broad market exposure and low costs, they come with a potential downside. The growing popularity of ETFs has led to the creation of highly specialised and complex products that stray from the simplicity that makes indexing so effective.

Excessive trading in ETFs, driven by their liquidity and tradability, can undermine the long-term benefits of low costs and tax efficiency. Investors should be cautious and limit ETF use to long-term core holdings and specific diversification goals. Speculating with ETFs defeats their purpose and erodes returns over time.

Putting Theory into Practice

At the heart of common sense investing is a simple principle: you don’t need to outperform the market to succeed. Instead, strive to *be* the market by embracing low-cost index funds. This approach will spare you from the inevitable disappointments of speculative investing and help you achieve your financial goals in the long run.

By investing with discipline, sticking to broad diversification, and avoiding the urge to chase short-term gains, you’ll find that the simplest strategy often yields the best results.

“For the investor, a too-high purchase price for the stock of an excellent company can undo the effects of a subsequent decade of favorable…
WELCOME BACK
Let´s create your 100%-free membership, instantly
This link is already saved
Your link has been saved

Welcome. Please set your update preferences (Optional. Default = all)

BLOOMBERG GLOBAL NEWS

Bloomberg video news feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

RBA ECONOMIC UPDATES

Periodic updates on the Australian economy, direct from the RBA, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

US FEDERAL RESERVE UPDATES

Bloomberg News focussed upon the Federal Reserve, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

FX/GLOBAL BRIEFS

Brief global updates with a focus upon currencies, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

ASX MARKET UPDATES

ASX-focussed updates, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

BLOOMBERG BRIEFS

Global briefs from Bloomberg with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED