Home
IU

Diving Deep into Expected Value and Statistical Edge: Considering an Advanced Version of Van Tharp’s Marble Game

Introduction

In the intricate world of trading and investment, various mathematical and probabilistic tools help professionals make informed decisions. Among these, the concepts of probability, objective reasoning, and expected value stand out for their fundamental significance. Utilising a seemingly simple yet profound illustrative tool, Van Tharp’s Marble Game, we can gain profound insights into these pivotal concepts.

The Bedrock: Understanding Probability and Objective Reasoning

Before delving into the marble game, it’s crucial to understand the foundational concepts:

  • Probability: At its core, probability quantifies the likelihood of an event occurring. Represented as a value between 0 and 1 (or 0% and 100%), it provides a mathematical measure of uncertainty. In trading, probability helps quantify the potential success or failure of an investment.
  • Objective Reasoning: This is the practice of making decisions based on factual and unbiased information. In the investment world, objective reasoning demands that choices be made on hard data, clear analysis, and without emotional influence. This ensures decisions are rooted in reality, not swayed by hopes or fears.
Van Tharp’s Original Marble Game: A Primer

Van Tharp’s original Marble Game is a beginner’s gateway to understanding risk, reward, and randomness in trading. Imagine a bag containing two types of marbles:

  • Green Marbles: Representing winning trades.
  • Red Marbles: Representing losing trades.

By drawing marbles one by one, recording outcomes, and replacing them, traders get a visceral understanding of random sequences and how, despite a higher number of winning marbles, a series of losses can still occur. This sequence randomness illustrates the unpredictability inherent in trading, emphasizing the importance of strategy and risk management.

The Advanced Marble Game: Adding Layers of Complexity

Building on the original’s foundation, the advanced version introduces more marble colours, each with unique payouts and probabilities:

  • Green Marble: A 2% capital gain with a 40% occurrence probability.
  • Red Marble: A 1% capital loss, occurring 50% of the time.
  • Blue Marble: A lucrative 5% gain, but only at an 8% likelihood.
  • Yellow Marble: A 3% loss, with a rare 2% occurrence rate.

Each draw from the bag represents a trade, giving a richer, more varied experience of trading outcomes and their probabilities.

Expected Value (EV): The Mathematical Compass of Decision Making

Expected value melds probability with potential payout, offering an average result one could expect over multiple instances:

EV = (Probability of Outcome) × (Payout of Outcome)

Calculating the EV for each marble:

  1. Green Marble: EV = 0.40 × 0.02 = 0.008 or 0.8%
  2. Red Marble: EV = 0.50 × -0.01 = -0.005 or -0.5%
  3. Blue Marble: EV = 0.08 × 0.05 = 0.004 or 0.4%
  4. Yellow Marble: EV = 0.02 × -0.03 = -0.0006 or -0.06%

Summing these gives a total EV of 0.64%. This positive value suggests that over time, one would gain an average of 0.64% of their capital for each draw.

Statistical Edge in Trading

With the EV in hand, traders can ascertain their statistical edge—a measure of the advantage or disadvantage of a trading strategy. A positive EV indicates a strategy with a statistical edge, meaning it’s likely to be profitable over many trades. Conversely, a negative EV suggests potential losses over the long run.

The Implications and Real-world Applications

The advanced marble game encapsulates several vital trading tenets:

  • Diverse Outcomes: Markets offer varied outcomes, much like the different coloured marbles. Each has its associated risks and rewards.
  • Risk Management: A trader must safeguard against consecutive adverse outcomes, just as one might encounter a streak of red marbles.
  • Position Sizing: With the knowledge of different outcomes and their EVs, traders can adjust their position sizes to align with potential risks and rewards.
Conclusion

Van Tharp’s Marble Game, in its original and advanced forms, offers an intuitive understanding of complex trading principles. By embracing the game’s lessons on probability, expected value, and statistical edge, traders can better navigate the uncertain waters of the financial markets, making decisions rooted in objective reasoning and sound mathematics.

“A peak performance trader is totally committed to being the best and doing whatever it takes to be the best. He feels totally responsible for whatever happens and thus can learn from mistakes. These people typically have a working business plan for trading because they treat trading as a business. ” – Van K. Tharp

sc name=”fma-cta”]

BLOOMBERG GLOBAL NEWS

Bloomberg video news feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

RBA ECONOMIC UPDATES

Periodic updates on the Australian economy, direct from the RBA, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

US FEDERAL RESERVE UPDATES

Bloomberg News focussed upon the Federal Reserve, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

FX/GLOBAL BRIEFS

Brief global updates with a focus upon currencies, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

ASX MARKET UPDATES

ASX-focussed updates, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED

BLOOMBERG BRIEFS

Global briefs from Bloomberg with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
CHARTS + FEED