From Witch Trials to Wall Street: The Timeless Spell of Confirmation Bias

Imagine a world where mere suspicion can lead to ruinous outcomes. This was the reality of the witch trials – a stark metaphor for the perils of confirmation bias in today’s financial markets. In this exploration, we delve into the psychology of trading, unearthing lessons from the past to navigate the complex world of investment.

Decoding Confirmation Bias: A Tale of Two Eras

Picture the scene: a village, gripped by fear, turns on one of its own, seeing signs of witchcraft in every shadow. This was the grim reality of the witch trials, a period marked by hysteria and irrationality. Now, fast-forward to the present day. The trading floor, not so dissimilar, where investors and traders are often caught in the web of their own preconceptions, seeing what they want to see in market trends and data. In both cases, the root cause is confirmation bias – a psychological phenomenon where individuals favour information that confirms their existing beliefs and ignore or undervalue what contradicts them.

In the world of trading and investment, confirmation bias is not just a theoretical concept; it’s a practical reality with real financial implications. For instance, consider a trader who firmly believes in the potential of a particular technology stock. Every piece of positive news about the company or its sector is seized upon as proof of this belief, while negative reports are dismissed or rationalised away. This can lead to a distorted view of the stock’s actual value and potential, not unlike how villagers in the witch trials would interpret every milk spoilage or unexplained illness as evidence of witchcraft.

aelv a surreal scene of a witch on trial at a Salem witch trial bfeadda7 ae6b 436f 91f4 5378d4270571

It’s a phenomenon that’s all too human. We seek patterns, we crave certainty, and we cling to our beliefs. In the stock market, this can manifest in various ways. An investor might hold onto a losing stock, convinced it will rebound, despite mounting evidence to the contrary. Or a trader might jump onto a ‘hot’ investment trend, swayed by the frenzy of the crowd, without doing their due diligence. The echo of the witch trials resounds in these modern halls of finance, where the flames of confirmation bias can consume rational thought and lead to costly mistakes.

This cognitive bias can affect even the most seasoned investors. It’s not just about being wrong on a particular stock or market trend; it’s about how we process and react to information. Do we seek diverse perspectives? Do we challenge our assumptions? Or do we, like the witch trial judges, only see what we expect to see? The answers to these questions can mean the difference between a successful investment strategy and a cautionary tale of what happens when confirmation bias goes unchecked.

Casting Spells on Data: The Witch Trial Approach in Modern Trading

Just as the witch trials of old were guided by superstition and fear, modern traders can sometimes be misled by their own psychological biases. These biases, akin to the flawed ‘tests’ of the witch trials, can distort an investor’s perception of market realities.

  • Technical Analysis as a Crystal Ball: Over-reliance on technical analysis in trading can mirror the Trial by Ordeal approach, like the infamous Swimming Test. Investors often view technical charts as infallible indicators, much like how villagers viewed water’s reaction to a suspected witch as an unequivocal sign of guilt or innocence.
  • The Pricking Test of Market Trends: Selective interpretation of market data is similar to the witch-hunt practice of the Pricking Test. Traders may focus on data that confirms their existing beliefs about a stock, akin to how retractable needles were used to ‘prove’ the presence of witch marks.
  • Weighing Sentiment Against Reality: Just like in the Witchcraft trials, where suspects were weighed against the Bible, traders can give undue importance to market sentiment, mistaking hype for genuine investment potential.
  • The Touch Test of Peer Influence: Relying on consensus or expert opinion can resemble the Touch Test, where the reaction of a witch’s alleged victim was considered proof of guilt. Similarly, traders might mistake market consensus as a reliable indicator of a sound investment decision.

These modern-day equivalents of witch trial ‘tests’ highlight the importance of objective analysis in trading, underscoring the need to look beyond personal biases and popular opinion to make informed investment decisions.

Trading Alchemy: Transmuting Bias into Balanced Judgement

To effectively navigate the complex terrain of financial markets, a blend of scepticism and data-driven analysis is essential. This means not just relying on gut feelings or market trends, but engaging in a rigorous process of questioning and validation. Challenging preconceived notions is akin to an alchemist’s quest – transforming the base metal of bias into the gold of balanced judgement. This involves delving into comprehensive research, examining trends from multiple angles, and being open to adapting strategies in response to new information. It’s a process that requires not just understanding the data, but also understanding oneself – recognising personal biases and actively working to mitigate their influence. This balanced approach, combining scepticism with a scientific mindset, equips traders with the tools to make more informed decisions, free from the deceptive allure of confirmation bias.

From Historical Shadows to Enlightened Investing

The witch trials of the past, with their shadowy superstitions and unfounded accusations, offer a stark contrast to the enlightened approach required in modern trading. In the world of investment, confronting and overcoming inherent biases is not just a recommendation, it’s a necessity. This involves a continuous process of learning and unlearning, of questioning not just the markets but also one’s approach to them. By acknowledging and addressing our cognitive biases, we can transform our investment strategies and decision-making processes. This journey towards enlightened investing leads to not only wiser financial choices but also a deeper understanding of the markets and ourselves. It’s about moving from a place of fear and speculation to a position of knowledge and strategy, leveraging insights from the past to illuminate the path forward in the world of finance.

Charting Your Course: Steering Clear of Confirmation Bias in Your Trading and Investing

As we reflect on the lessons from the witch trials and their relevance to modern trading, here’s a guide to avoiding confirmation bias in your own investment strategies:

  • Question Your Choices: Regularly challenge your investment decisions. Are they based on solid data or preconceived notions?
  • Diversify Information Sources: Seek information from a variety of sources to get a well-rounded view of the market and potential investments.
  • Test Against Data: Rigorously evaluate your hypotheses with market data and trends, ensuring your decisions are grounded in reality.
  • Value Evidence Over Emotion: Make investment decisions based on evidence and analysis rather than emotional reactions or popular sentiment.
  • Critical Thinking: Foster a mindset that prioritises critical thinking and objective analysis over following the crowd.
  • Identify and Counteract Biases: Actively work to recognise your own biases and take steps to mitigate their impact on your investment decisions.

By embracing these strategies, you embark on a path towards more thoughtful, balanced, and ultimately more successful trading and investing decisions, guided by wisdom and insight rather than superstition and bias.

“The goal of the good trader, paradoxically, is not to make money. His goal is to trade well.” – Alexander Elder

sc name=”fma-cta”]


Bloomberg video news feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals


Periodic updates on the Australian economy, direct from the RBA, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals


Bloomberg News focussed upon the Federal Reserve, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals


Brief global updates with a focus upon currencies, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals


ASX-focussed updates, with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals


Global briefs from Bloomberg with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals
Audio/video feed with live charts, watchlists & fundamentals